Menu of Red's Subs & Deli in Plymouth, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

Red's Subs & Deli, nestled on 173 E Main St in Plymouth, PA, is a testament to the classic American hoagie experience done right. This unassuming deli offers an impressive lineup of subs that capture the essence of fresh, hearty deli sandwiches without any pretense.

The menu showcases a variety of "Super Subs" like the hot ham and salami, ham and turkey, hot roast beef, and the ever-popular "Regular" sub. There’s something genuinely satisfying about their approach—it’s straightforward, emphasizing quality ingredients and precise craftsmanship. The fresh rolls are a highlight that customers frequently praise. These rolls act as the perfect vessel, soft yet sturdy enough to hold generous portions of freshly sliced meat, crisp lettuce, and ripe tomatoes.

What truly elevates Red's is the dedication to freshness. As noted by Cathy Torchia, the owner slices the meat fresh to order, maintaining impeccable cleanliness and a tightly run kitchen. This level of care translates directly into the taste. The meats, whether it’s ham, turkey, roast beef, or their specialty kielbasa, have a robust and authentic flavor profile that feels both comforting and satisfying.

The homemade kielbasa, mentioned in a local festival special, exemplifies the deli's commitment to flavor depth. It’s thick, juicy, with a smoky, savory note that pairs beautifully with the soft bun and the kick of hot mustard and onions. Even the "Regular" sub—a simple build of lettuce, tomato, onion, and mayo—delivers a perfect balance that makes it a fan favorite. Denise Devine’s enthusiastic recommendation of the "Regular Sub with everything" underscores just how a few quality ingredients can come together harmoniously.

Beyond the food, the customer service adds an emotional warmth to the visit. Stories of the owner graciously making subs minutes before closing—and refusing tips—illustrate a business that is as community-focused as it is quality-driven. The intimate bar stool seating and on-street metered parking reinforce a local, small-town charm that makes each visit feel personal and welcoming.

Red's Subs & Deli is more than just a sandwich shop. It is a place where the tradition of the American deli thrives—fresh, simple, and delicious. For anyone craving a genuine hoagie experience, this spot offers a consistent, flavorful journey worth repeating. It’s a stalwart on Plymouth’s culinary map and rightly earns a spot in any local food rotation.